Hotel Reviews

‘onefinestay’ in Marylebone, London – a luxury apartment rental review

Once a month, I stay in London during the week, which allows me to enjoy a bit more of ‘city life’ after client meetings. I usually stay in hotels (and you can read various reviews here on the blog), but this time around, I tried something different. onefinestay, who provide luxury apartment rentals in London, Paris, NYC, Los Angeles and now Rome, invited me to stay at one of their London properties.

If you think onefinestay follows the model of airbnb or something similar – forget about it. Every property on their books is exclusively theirs (and it is someone’s real home) and they offer all the services that make the onefinestay experience come to life – and I will show you what that means exactly in a minute. They are not a ‘platform’ where A and B come together – if you own a luxury home in one of their cities, onefinestay will manage your property for you and market it. The sheets, the towels, the cleaning crews, the concierge services – they are all theirs. And that was absolutely key for me – I really want to know I have someone I can call 24/7 in case something goes wrong.

I chose Marylebone as my London location – an area I know very well and absolutely love. I was sent a selection of available properties on my dates and overnight they were all booked bar 1. James Street II was the one left and the apartment where we stayed.

onefinestay london marylebone mayfair luxury apartment rental living room james II

Our London apartment in Marylebone.



You book through the website and/or telephone and you receive an email with all the information about your booking. For security reasons, you will need to name any other guests and are also invited to download the onefinestay app where you can manage your booking, find directions, things to do in the area and learn more about the property. I was super impressed with the process, to be honest.



We had organised for a 4pm check-in as I had other appointments later in the evening (coincidentally one of them being a reception organised by onefinestay to celebrate its recent acquisition by Accor Hotels). My check in host texted me to introduce himself and asked me to let him know when I was going to arrive so he would come down to the building door, let me in and also help me with my luggage.

My check-in time was slightly earlier than the onefinestay team had expected (but pre-agreed), so interestingly when I arrived, the cleaners were still on property. I actually found it fascinating to see how the final part was carried out – the supervisor took photos of every detail of the property, namely the security tags (more on those later) which I thought was very reassuring for both sides.

My check-in host walked me around the apartment, showing me where things were, how things worked and explained to me what the tags were – basically, all onefinestay apartments are real people’s homes so part of their personal property stays in the house, in cupboards/wardrobes, of course, which are sealed. If I tried to snoop around, the seal would break. Again, very clever.

onefinestay london marylebone mayfair james II luxury apartment rental app

Your own iPhone to be used during your stay.

I was also given my own iPhone with a local SIM card – which every guest gets and introduced to the onefinestay app, which really was useful. It included the house manual and instructions, one-click access to onefinestay’s team – by phone, text, email, whatever suited me -, and local recommendations which I particularly liked.

My ID was confirmed and verified and I also left a £1,000 security deposit (payment was taken by credit card over the phone during the check-in process).


The location

Our apartment was located on James Street, in Marylebone, across the road from St. Christopher’s Place. It had 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a living room/kitchen/dining room. Interestingly, there were some mentions of Mayfair as the neighbourhood, but it absolutely isn’t as it is on the North side of Oxford Street. In all honesty, I did want an apartment in Marylebone, one of the few central London neighbourhoods who really still feels like a (lovely) village and I did not understand why the need to mention Mayfair at all. I love Mayfair, don’t get me wrong – I really do.

James Street is busy and close to many outdoor restaurants and cafes – I was worried about the noise at night, but have nothing to report on that front. Everything shut before 11pm and the double-glazing did its job well.

We had 2 sets of keys and never had a problem.


The apartment 

The apartment was light, bright and spacious, as you can see from the photos below.


Master bedroom

onefinestay london marylebone mayfair james II luxury apartment rental master master bedroom 1

The master bedroom

This was the most ‘clinical’ room in the house, decor-wise but very functional. We had half of the wardrobe for our own use and access to an en suite bathroom.

It lacked a full-length mirror (which I suspect would be inside the sealed wardrobe doors) and I asked if it would be possible to have one – magically, the next day it appeared while I was out in meetings. The hairdryer (which you can see on the right bedside table) also wasn’t excellent, and would be one of the details I would improve.

onefinestay london marylebone mayfair james II luxury apartment rental master bedroom 1

Notice a little dot on the wardrobe doors to the left – the security seal.

The mattress and bed linen were great – no complaints there – but I found the pillows too hard, and so did Mr. O, who is not as picky as me in this department. As a proud owner of Sofitel pillows at home (which are the best ever), I hope this is one of the areas that can be improved – it really would make for an excellent addition to the experience. On a personal note, I did not love having the towels on the bed – I would have preferred for them to be in their place, in the bathroom.


The master bathroom

onefinestay london marylebone mayfair luxury apartment rental master amenities bathroom1

A very sexy bathroom

I loved the bathroom. And what I loved about it the most is that it had the same Hansgrohe taps and ‘Starck for Duravit’ loo we have at home. I know how much these cost (believe me) and the whole apartment really was very well appointed, so to speak.

This bathroom had an unusual layout with a bath tub and then a walk-in shower, which I thought it was a very clever use of space. We had 2 sets of towels and The White Company toiletries which were very nice. We had enough for more than the 3 days of our stay.

onefinestay london marylebone mayfair luxury apartment rental bathroom 1

The master bathroom


The second bedroom and bathroom

onefinestay london marylebone mayfair james II luxury apartment rental bedroom 2

The second bedroom

The apartment had a twin second bedroom and a separate bathroom which followed the same clean design and high spec. We did not use them during our stay.

onefinestay london marylebone mayfair luxury apartment rental bathroom 2

The second bathroom



onefinestay london marylebone mayfair james II luxury apartment rental master amenities kitchen facilities

The kitchen

The kitchen, dining area and lounge were all in the same room and I thought the space flowed well – the kitchen had everything you could need and more – and I did appreciate the Miele appliances. Obviously it had a coffee maker, a kettle and a variety of cooking appliances (which we did not use). I did like that the pots & pans were the same Le Creuset ones we have at home – but again, we only had wine and used the fridge for drinks. I almost had a ‘seal’ tampering episode once I opened the fridge as I saw a perfume bottle and was going to put it away. But then realised that these items were left intentionally there and obviously did not touch them!

onefinestay london marylebone mayfair james II luxury apartment rental master amenities kitchen details 2

Kitchen details

We had a little welcome hamper which included milk, tea, bottled water, popcorn and some other small items. I liked that there were plenty of books and useful guides which I had a look at. I tell no lies!

onefinestay london marylebone mayfair james II luxury apartment rental master amenities keys detail

Details – and the full length mirror that made me very happy!


Dining/Lounge Area

onefinestay london marylebone mayfair luxury apartment rental living room

The living room and dining area

I ended up spending part of my days here, and found it a very nice place to work – and watch a bit of TV. It offered Sky satellite, so I knew how to work the controls and found it very homely.

WiFi was very fast and there were plugs everywhere for all the devices you could want. There was also a washing machine (which we did not use), ironing board and iron (which we did use).



I had to check out early in the morning, so I was told to leave the iPhone charging (which I did, of course), and the keys on the kitchen table. I later received a text message confirming everything was fine and my deposit was returned quickly.


Final thoughts

We had a very comfortable stay at this apartment and bizarrely it did feel like home. I know the area very well and booked all my meetings nearby and kept coming in and out of the apartment and loved having a key.


Things that can be improved:

  • Pillows and hairdryer
  • Having towels on the towel rack

Things that I loved:

  • I loved knowing that I had someone to call at any time not only if something went wrong, but also if I wanted, say, restaurant reservations. I felt there was a real company behind it, and a very professional one at that.
onefinestay london marylebone mayfair james II luxury apartment rental master amenities keys detail 2


  • The app was very clever – and they made it super easy to get in touch with the team. And I loved the ‘Call an Uber’ feature – you didn’t even have to know your address.
  • House was spotless and I felt comfortable using everything that was at my disposal


Have you stayed at an apartment during a trip? What were your thoughts?



Mrs. O


Disclaimer: I was a guest of onefinestay on this occasion and really enjoyed the service. Opinions are, as always, my own – and I have no problem recommending it to any of my readers. Prices for a one night stay at James Street II start from £240 per night based on two people staying at the flat and including all onefinestay services. To book or for more information visit or call + 44 207 167 2524. 

Article was posted on
View Comments (9)


  1. Kathryn (Boutique Travel Blog)

    July 5, 2016 at 7:58 pm

    What a lovely apartment and the company obviously know what they are doing (apart from maybe the pillows – have to agree with you there). I’d not heard of them before so thank you for the introduction.
    Kathryn (Boutique Travel Blog) recently posted..Review: LaFavia, boutique B&B in MilanMy Profile

  2. Shikha (whywasteannualleave)

    June 14, 2016 at 1:33 pm

    What a great concept Ana! Such a wonderful spacious property it seems particularly given its unbeatable location!
    Shikha (whywasteannualleave) recently posted..A Dreamy Luxury Honeymoon at Breezes Beach Club & Spa, ZanzibarMy Profile

    • @mrsoaroundworld

      June 15, 2016 at 12:21 pm

      I really loved it – and would have no issue doing it again!

  3. Suze - Luxury Columnist

    June 9, 2016 at 10:56 am

    I like the fact that they use security seals to secure the owner’s belongings, and I’m a Hansgrohe fan too!
    Suze – Luxury Columnist recently posted..Notting Hill Hidden Gems & The Best Pedicure in LondonMy Profile

  4. Amie O'Shaughnessy

    June 6, 2016 at 9:46 pm

    We book One Fine Stay for our clients regularly. Two thumbs up!
    Amie O’Shaughnessy recently posted..Best Things to Do in South Tyrol, Italy with KidsMy Profile

    • @mrsoaroundworld

      June 7, 2016 at 8:15 am

      That is great to know 🙂 I really liked the whole concept

  5. MissLilly

    June 6, 2016 at 9:23 pm

    had no idea there was such a lovely service around and love the concept! Beautiful apartment 🙂

    • @mrsoaroundworld

      June 7, 2016 at 8:15 am

      It was gorgeous – and the concept really works too. I thought the extra services were fantastic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More in Hotel Reviews

Jagdhof Luxury Ski Hotel Relais Chateau Neustift im Stubaital 30 minutes Stubaier Gletscher ski area mountain cover

Luxury Hotel Review: Jagdhof Hotel in Neustift, Austria

@mrsoaroundworldMarch 8, 2019
Park Igls detox medical spa austria innsbruck mayr cure diet setting cover

Wellness Review: Park Igls Mayr health retreat, Austria

@mrsoaroundworldFebruary 6, 2019
the golden door luxury destination spa and retreat weight loss san diego southern california near los angeles newport beach

Wellness Review: The Golden Door Spa, California

@mrsoaroundworldDecember 4, 2018
almar jesolo luxury hotel lido jesolo venice italy wellness healing hotel cover

A hotel to remember: a review of Almar Jesolo, Italy

@mrsoaroundworldSeptember 6, 2018
miami florida luxury hotel review four seasons hotel at the surf club surfside oceanfront twin room COVER

A Hotel to Remember: a Review of the Four Seasons Hotel at The Surf Club, Surfside in Florida

@mrsoaroundworldJuly 25, 2018
puente romano marbella luxury hotel review leading hotel of the world spain sovereign luxury travel cover

A hotel to remember: a review of Puente Romano, Marbella, Spain

@mrsoaroundworldJune 4, 2018


Please note that some of the links on this website are affiliate links, and at no additional cost to you, I will earn a commission if you decide to make a purchase after clicking through the link.

Love Travel. Love People.

Love Shoes.

Copyright © 2018 Ana Silva O'Reilly.

%d bloggers like this: